Wednesday 14 November 2007

Obsession with Doctors

Since I was a child my parents kept telling me that I will one day become a doctor. Without a second thought I would always agree with them. As I grew older and graduated from school, I discovered I had more of an interest towards engineering subjects. However my parents were still adamant that I would become a doctor.

When I started applying for University, I was forced to keep the subject of my degree a secret but eventually my parents found out and there was a huge quarrel about it. It took a lot of persuasion and many arguments later I managed to convince them. Seeing my passion for engineering they vowed their support.

I felt like I have changed my family’s mind about enforcing what they want on us. I was mistaken. In the recent months, my nephew had to go through exactly what I did. If it was just an issue in my own family perhaps I wouldn’t be so worried but this obsession exists in most Afghan families.

I can’t speak for other professions but if you are an engineering enthusiast and having similar problems with your family here are some of the arguments that will help you fight for your right.

One of the arguments my parents gave me was that doctors are the healers and saviours of human being, which is true. However, engineers are the not only the saviours of human beings but also the providers of the convenience. Everything we see around us that wasn’t made by God is the creation of Engineers.

Without engineers there would be no ambulances to get the critically ill people to hospitals, doctors and surgeons would have no tools to operate on patients, there would be no x-rays or other technology to diagnose illnesses, all in all there would be no hospitals with out engineers.

There would be no roads without engineers, no electricity, no aeroplanes, no cars, no ipods, no laptops, no toys, no dolls, no bridges, no boats, no buildings, well basically nothing. Look around you, well there would be none of that without engineers.

From the early days of the world, the engineers have made the lives of other humans easy. Those with engineering minds dug caves for shelter. It is the blessing of engineers, who invented the printing machine, which made education accessible to all. Without this invention, most people won’t be able to afford books.

With computers, engineers made life even easier for every one on this earth. Communication is almost free these days but more than that learning about any subject is only a click away.

Engineers didn’t stop with providing all the needs but continued with entertainment for everyone. Radios, televisions, DVD’s, ipods, etc are all gifts of the engineers.

You would think that would be it but fortunately it doesn’t stop there. It took an engineer to work out the causes of the deadly Malaria, which claimed many innocent lives, just like cancer before an engineer working in a mine found a cure for it. Cancer is another example of engineering research. The amount of contribution engineers make towards medical advancement is immense. You could call engineers the real healers :)

This is just an example but if you do show you are so passionate about what you want to do then there would be no problems. It is also advisable to do a detailed research about your choice because nothing is worth doing without absolute passion.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hahahhaaah lol You Joker!!!

Good for you Mohib Jaan, I on the other hand couldnt be bothered for any debates or arguments lol so i just went for medicine! lol

Anonymous said...

well he had to make use of his natural argumentative talent somehow lol...

Unknown said...

Hamdullah jan,

It is so nice to read my own thoughts on your blog, written by you :)

I went through that dilema of what profession i would go into, and i with a bit of resistance, i went for Engineering :)

Obviously, our Afghan parents are obssessed by Doctors: there could only be 2 reasons for that:
1- There is not such a as a Healthy Afghan :) My own parents have 101 illnesses (according to themselves), so naturally they expect their children to become Doctors to cure them :)

2- It is generally accepted that Doctors make more money than others, and as Afghans we know our passion for money :) (I know this is not a well founded reason, but it is there)

seb said...

it is a very good point nearly all afgans want to be doctors,
we should try engeneering with out them loads of things wouldnt of happend

Anonymous said...

May I add that 90% of diagnosis is based on clinical examination in the UK. Technology is only used to confirm diagnosis. I do not believe without technology there would be no medicine.

In the USA technology is being exploited, doctors are so good at their clinician examinations as UK doctors, because they rely on technology to make diagnosis. That why UK doctors Rock!!!!!

Doctors are known to have existed since the 1518's. Where was your technology then.

Antibiotics has been the greatest invention in medicine, not engineering.

If I could choose between a doctor or an engineer survival. I would choose for doctors to survive. Its all about Survival of the fittest!!!!!!!!!

What Am i gonna do with an ipod or a laptop, when i am having a heart attack. I want a doctor to give me thromolysis and not an engineer offering me ipod. By the way heart attack can be managed without any use of technology!!!!!!


MedicGirlUK

Anonymous said...

correction above: .....USA doctors are NOT so good at their clinical examinations skills.....

Farhad Timuri said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Farhad Timuri said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Farhad Timuri said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Farhad Timuri said...

One compromise for those facing the dilemma between engineering and medicine would be choose a subject which links the two - Biomedical Engineering (aka Bioengineering)

My parents were keen that I did medicine but after spending two weeks at a hospital shadowing a junior doctor I realised that it was not for me.

Having studied Maths, Further Maths, Physics and Chemistry A Levels, I had fallen in love with differential equations far too much to give them up for, inter alia, the composition of mitochondria (celluar biology) or memorising the names of all the arterties in the body.

Also, what some parents must realise these days is that the university degree that you pursue does not necessarily mean that you will end up working in that field.

To give you personal example, I studied Bioengineering at Imperial College and at the end of the degree, I had two options:

i) pursue a PhD in applications of chaos theory in biomedical sigals (effectively to extend my final year thesis, combining cardiology / ECGs, non-linear dynamics - so a lot of crazy maths - and computing - for modelling the maths); or

ii) accept an offer to join Credit Suisse European mergers and acquistions team as a financial analyst

It was a tough choice but I ended up choosing the latter option for a variety of reasons (personal / career development being one of them).

People ask me "so was your university degree waste since you are not in the field anymore"? The answer is "Not at all!"

On the contrary, I am now able to sit down with the CEO / CFOs and management of mutli-million companies healthcare companies inolved in managing doctors, researchers, engineers, businesses, governments (and list is not exhaustive at all) on a daily basis. I wouldn't be able to do my job if I had not been able to develop my communication, organisational ("soft skills") and the technical skills at university.

A degree is as much about developing the non-academic skills as it is academic.

In my view, I think a university degree is just a stepping stone to achieving a lot more in life after university. I think the most important question is whether you think you will ENJOY the subject because when things get tough (and they do pretty quickly at university, as we all know) the only thing that will motivate you to continue will be YOUR, not your parents', interest in the subject.

Farhad